"A triumph! This baritone has the vocal wherewithal to do just about anything he wants."
-- The Boston Globe
"It is impossible to imagine Randall Scarlata singing a mechanical or thoughtless phrase. One has the wonderful sense that Scarlata searches out the Platonic essence of what he plans to sing and then uses every attribute at his disposal to create the most appropriate and fully dimensional realization possible."
-- The Washington Post
"Scarlata's singing was one of the highlights of the evening."
-- Opera News
"Randall Scarlata is an intelligent and communicative singer. His delivery of text was vivid, and this was not just a matter of clear diction but of a compelling desire to bring texts to life. His voice is hearty and robust, and his lovely, soft singing in high-lying phrases was poignant."
-- The New York Times